Tax Preparer vs. CPA: 6 Key Differences | Mark J. Kohler

 

If you’re navigating the tax industry—either as a professional looking to expand your expertise or a taxpayer seeking the right assistance—you might be wondering whether to hire a tax preparer vs CPA. 

While both professionals help individuals and businesses with taxes, their qualifications, services, earning potential, and authority vary significantly. Below, we break down the key differences between a tax preparer and CPA to help you determine which path suits your needs best.

 

1. What is the Difference Between a Tax Preparer and a CPA?

 

The biggest difference between tax preparer and CPA is education, certification, and the services they provide.

 

• Tax preparers focus on preparing and filing tax returns. They do not need a formal degree, though some take training courses.

 

• CPAs must have a bachelor’s degree, pass the CPA exam, and meet state licensing requirements. They are trained in accounting, auditing, tax planning, and financial consulting.

 

If you need simple tax filing, a tax preparer can handle it. But if you need financial advice, tax planning, or IRS representation, a CPA is a better choice.

 

2. Can a Tax Preparer File Taxes for a Business?

 

Yes, but with limitations.

 

• Tax preparers can file business tax returns for small businesses, freelancers, and self-employed individuals.

 

• Enrolled Agents (EAs) have additional certification and can represent businesses before the IRS.

 

• CPAs can handle complex business tax situations, offer tax planning, and provide long-term financial strategy.

 

If you own a business and need more than just tax filing, a CPA is the better choice.

 

3. How Do the Qualifications of a CPA Compare to a Tax Preparer?

 

• Tax preparers do not need a degree and typically complete training programs or become Enrolled Agents (EAs). Their main job is to file tax returns accurately.

 

• CPAs must earn a bachelor’s degree, pass the CPA exam, and meet state licensing requirements. This allows them to offer tax planning, auditing, and business consulting.

 

• Only CPAs, EAs, and tax attorneys can fully represent clients before the IRS.

 

If you need tax filing only, a tax preparer works fine. If you need financial planning or IRS representation, a CPA is a better investment.

 

4. Do CPAs Charge More Than Tax Preparers?

 

Yes. CPAs generally charge higher fees because they offer more services and have extensive training.

 

• Tax preparers charge between $150 and $400 per return, depending on complexity.

 

• CPAs charge between $500 and $2,000 or more, especially for business tax planning and consulting.

 

If you need a simple return, a tax preparer is a cost-effective option. If you want tax strategy or business advice, paying more for a CPA can save money in the long run.

 

5. Is a Tax Preparer a CPA?

 

No, a tax preparer is not a CPA unless they have completed the required education, passed the CPA exam, and obtained state licensure. A CPA has a much broader skill set and can provide financial advisory services beyond tax preparation.

 

6. Which is Better for Tax Filing, a CPA or a Tax Preparer?

 

It depends on your needs:

 

• Use a tax preparer if you just need a basic tax return filed with no complications.

 

• Hire a CPA if you need tax planning, audit support, financial consulting, or business tax strategy.

 

Final Thoughts: Should You Choose a CPA or a Tax Preparer?

 

Again, it depends on what you’re looking for and goals you’re looking to achieve.

• For simple tax returns, a tax preparer is a great choice.

 

• For complex tax situations, a CPA offers more expertise and long-term financial benefits.

 

BONUS: Become a Main Street Certified Tax Advisor 

 

For tax professionals looking to elevate their career, becoming a Main Street Certified Tax Advisor offers unparalleled advantages:

 

Higher Earnings – Offer advisory services and charge premium rates.

Professional Network – Gain access to mentorship, client referrals, and education.

Specialized Knowledge – Master tax planning, small business consulting, and financial strategy.

 

Want to boost your earning potential and career stability? This is where you start!

Learn more about becoming a Main Street Certified Tax Advisor and take the next step toward professional success. Call 520-800-0986 or schedule your FREE discovery call with our friendly team today!

REMINDER: Don’t forget to pick up your FREE tax guide today and learn how to build a profitable business/practice.