Protect Yourself From Your Rental: 5 Essential Strategies for Landlords

Get Mark’s Weekly Newsletter

Have exclusive insights, empowering wisdom, and game-changing strategies delivered to your inbox every week.

Mark J. Kohler August 29, 2025 • 4 min

Mark J. Kohler, CPA and attorney, has helped millions of Americans improve their finances through practical, trustworthy tax and wealth strategies. Mark's mission is simple: deliver credible, actionable financial advice and guidance you can always rely on.

Business Building

Owning rentals is a powerful way to build wealth, but it also puts a target on your back. Tenants, lawsuits, and liability can turn steady cash flow into a financial nightmare if you’re not protected. The key? A multi-barrier approach, stacking layers of defense so it’s harder for anyone to reach your personal assets.

These are the most important steps every landlord should take to protect themselves:

1. Put Rentals in an Entity (Not in Your Own Name)

This one’s non-negotiable. If you own rentals in your personal name, you’re gambling with your home, retirement, and savings every time a tenant signs a lease.

An LLC is usually the way to go—and in most states, the cost is manageable. You don’t need an LLC for every single property, but don’t throw five rentals into one bucket either. At least start with one LLC and build out from there as your portfolio grows.

2. Be a Responsible Landlord

You can’t just cash rent checks and disappear. As a landlord, you have an inherent duty to keep your property in safe condition. The law doesn’t let you wash your hands of responsibility, even if you hire a property manager. If they screw up, you’re still in the crosshairs.

Landlord-tenant laws have only gotten stricter, so keep in mind:

Tenant protections are stronger than ever. Many states require “just cause” for eviction, longer notice periods, and limits on deposits or rent hikes.
Document everything. Move-in and move-out photos are cheap insurance—and in some states, they’re required.
Know your limits. You must act reasonably to prevent injuries, but you’re not the insurer of every freak accident. Courts expect you to be proactive, not perfect.

The theme? Follow the rules, be diligent, and document everything. These steps won’t make you bulletproof, but they add real layers of protection.

3. Have a Strong Lease Agreement

A sloppy lease is a lawsuit waiting to happen.

A solid lease should:

Spell out who’s responsible for rent, deposits, maintenance, and conduct.
Set clear rules on pets, smoking, and guests.
Provide remedies if the tenant defaults.

Even better, combine it with written policies and rules. A good lease doesn’t just protect your property, it can shift part of the liability back where it belongs: on the tenant.

4. Carry the Right Insurance

Entity protection and leases are great, but insurance is your first line of defense when something goes wrong. A tenant slip, a burst pipe, or a dog bite can turn into six figures in liability if you’re not covered properly.

At a minimum, make sure you have:

• Landlord insurance (not a homeowner’s policy).

• Umbrella liability coverage for extra protection across all rentals and personal assets.

• Loss-of-rents coverage in case a property becomes uninhabitable.

The catch: insurance isn’t bulletproof anymore. Carriers are raising premiums, narrowing coverage, and denying claims if they can argue negligence. That’s why annual policy reviews—and good documentation of your property’s condition—are critical. Think of insurance as your seatbelt: necessary, but not the only protection you need.

5. Know What Risks You’re Liable For

Courts look at what you knew, or reasonably should have known, about your property. If the hazard was obvious, foreseeable, or reported to you, you’re more likely to be on the hook.

Common risks that lead to landlord liability include:

• Dangerous animals or pets.

• Poor maintenance, faulty construction, or mold/water damage.

• Broken security features in high-crime areas.

• Violations of building codes or safety ordinances.

• Tenant misconduct you ignored (parties, hazards, nuisance behavior).

The Bottom Line

Ignorance isn’t always a defense. If you knew, or reasonably should have known, about the problem, you’ll often be held responsible.

Protecting yourself as a landlord isn’t about one magic tool, it’s about stacking defenses. Entity structure, strong leases, proper insurance, and proactive maintenance all create barriers between you and liability. At KKOS Lawyers, we help landlords across the country set up LLCs, review leases, and build legal structures that actually hold up when challenged. Book a comprehensive tax and legal consult at kkoslawyers.com to make sure your rentals build wealth, not put it at risk.

Put these protections in place now, and you’ll sleep better knowing your investments—and your personal assets—are secure.

Related Topics

Mark J. Kohler